Truth or Dare by audience
The “I Had a Plan” Interview: Turn an Everyday Failure Into a Funny Story
A two-person adult game about one optimistic plan, its exact turning point, and the lesson nobody requested, with a full interview example.
Open the matching wheelA shortcut interview, including the award
Use this invented exchange to demonstrate the format. It is deliberately a small failure rather than a dramatic confession.
- Interviewer: “What was the plan?” Teller: “Walk through the park and beat my friend to the café.”
- Interviewer: “When did it go wrong?” Teller: “At the locked exit. I could see the café. The café could probably see my confidence leaving.”
- Interviewer: “What did you do next?” Teller: “Walked all the way back and arrived behind my friend, who had stopped to buy a newspaper.”
- Interviewer: “For Outstanding Commitment to the Scenic Route.” Teller: “I would like to thank the gate for making the lesson extremely clear.”
That is a complete turn. Swap roles rather than asking the teller for the worst thing that has ever happened to them. A small story with a visible turning point does not need to be escalated.
Choose a plan small enough to laugh about now
“I was going to take a shortcut” has somewhere to go. “My whole life is a disaster” asks the room to do a different job. Pick a minor incident the storyteller is comfortable revisiting: fixing a squeak, finding a parking space, making an overambitious cake, or finally sorting a drawer. A fictional example is fine if the group agrees. The story belongs to the person telling it, including the right to leave other people unnamed. For a broader mix of questions and performances, start with the adult friends round.
The interviewer gets three questions
Ask “What was the plan?”, “When did you realize it was going wrong?”, and “What did you do next?” in that order. These questions collect a sequence, not proof. Resist asking for every date, price, or person involved. If the answer is already a complete little story, let it end. If it wanders, ask for the exact moment the plan changed: the cake slid, the shortcut met a locked gate, or the squeak turned out to be the chair you were sitting on. That turning point is usually more useful than extra background.
Give the teller an award that belongs to this incident
The interviewer invents a short award title using one detail they just heard: Outstanding Confidence in an Unmeasured Gap, or Services to Searching the Bag Already on Your Shoulder. The teller accepts with one sentence. Avoid a permanent nickname or a sweeping judgment about their competence. The award belongs to that incident and expires with the turn. This little performance gives a story an ending without demanding a bigger embarrassment. Swap roles before starting another interview.
Keep a detail, drop a tangent
The takeaway is one scene someone can picture. “I carried the ladder through three rooms before checking whether it folded” is more memorable than an inventory of the whole garage. When you tell the story yourself, include the confident assumption and the moment it failed. When you listen, do not improve the story by inserting a different person’s embarrassing memory. The truth-question guide covers useful follow-ups for a general round; this interview keeps the same three questions so every player gets the same manageable assignment.
Eight starting plans for the interview
- I could fix the squeak without moving the furniture.
- The shortcut would definitely save time.
- I could carry all the shopping in one trip.
- There was no reason to measure the gap first.
- I would remember which car-park level this was.
- The simple cake decoration would only take a minute.
- I could identify the right cable without labeling anything.
- I would put it somewhere so safe that I could not possibly lose it.